Random Thoughts

There was a question on the Neo4j Google Group about returning results in a random order in Cypher.

CREATE (Neo:Crew { name:'Neo' }),
  (Morpheus:Crew { name: 'Morpheus' }),
 (Trinity:Crew { name: 'Trinity' }),
 (Cypher:Crew:Matrix { name: 'Cypher' }),
 (Smith:Matrix { name: 'Agent Smith' }),
 (Architect:Matrix { name:'The Architect'}),
 (Neo)-[:KNOWS]->(Morpheus),(Neo)-[:LOVES]->(Trinity),
 (Morpheus)-[:KNOWS]->(Trinity),(Morpheus)-[:KNOWS]->(Cypher),
 (Cypher)-[:KNOWS]->(Smith),(Smith)-[:CODED_BY]->(Architect)

First Try

The naive approach is just to order by rand():

MATCH (n:Crew)
RETURN n
ORDER BY rand()

Which fails with:

ORDER BY expressions must be deterministic. For instance, you cannot use the rand() function in the expression

That’s explainable, how would you order by something that generates a new value on each call.

Working Query

So we have to associate a random value with each row. Fortunately that’s easy with WITH:

MATCH (n:Crew)
WITH n, rand() AS r
ORDER BY r
RETURN n

So WITH n, rand() as r adds a new column called r (we need the alias) to each row, then we can order by that as part of with (we could even paginate) but in the RETURN clause we only return n and don’t expose r.

This approach is also handy if you want to order by things that you don’t want to expose later on.

Useful concept

Like ordering by the name of the person, but returning the friends in that order:

MATCH (n:Crew)-[:KNOWS]->(o)
WITH n.name as name, o
ORDER BY name DESC
RETURN o

Is this page helpful?

GraphGists

Random Thoughts

First Try

Working Query

Useful concept